Nonetheless, high grade examples are worth many multiples of their intrinsic value, which is enticing to counterfeiters. For a counterfeiter, the addition of a simple, small design element (an “S” mintmark or “V.D.B.” initials) can make a very cheap coin appear to be worth hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars. According to a press release from the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation, the firm that authenticated the coin, the San Francisco mint produced just 268 $5 gold coins… The 2005-dated quarter-ounce South African Krugerrand labeled NGC Proof 70 counterfeit coin housed in a counterfeit Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) holder that has the same certification number on the label as a genuine 2005 PF 70 one-quarter ounce Krugerrand listed in the NGC. Counterfeits of the gold bullion coin as well as grading service holders are known. PCGS holders are made of a more brittle plastic and will always crack open unevenly and with damage. Most fakes seen today are from that era. February 13, 2019. NGC graders look for these repeating depressions as well as overall weak details to identify fakes made from transfer dies. In another case presented in May to the ACEF, a buyer was bilked out of $8,000 spent on the Mercari e-commerce platform for counterfeit U.S. coins housed in fake … Because Seller had a 100% rating, I thought I was buying from a reputable person. Counterfeit Detection: 1903-O Morgan Dollar. The next coin is an Australian 1892-M sovereign, also counterfeit. Even the most skilled coin doctor will always leave behind “tool marks,” which are lines left by the tool used to sculpt the new date. Only 10,500 mint state examples were struck by Philadelphia that year, but this is not a low mintage for the unpopular gold dollar series. “NGC is now the official … This allows an enterprising counterfeiter to buy one gold double eagle for near melt and transform it into twenty gold dollar fakes which bring many multiples of their gold value. They are created by pressing the genuine piece into a soft material, thereby creating a negative impression. Read more >, For the fourteenth coin on our list, we return to the most-counterfeited series: the Indian Head gold $2.50. NGC should be notified though, because someone is going to get soaked for $1300. With a mintage of just under 500,000 coins, the 1910 Quarter Eagle is certainly not an overall rarity, but Mint State examples are actually quite elusive. The counterfeit label text font is narrower than NGC’s font. A major topic was counterfeit NGC holders and what is being done about them. Silver tarnishes extremely quickly when exposed to an oxidizing agent such as bleach. Talk about it on the NGC Chat Boards >. Genuine 2011-W American Buffalo gold coin, graded Proof 70 Ultra Cameo, in genuine NGC holder. Second, and of greater concern, it marks yet another fake Morgan Silver Dollar discovery in a two-year period. The fakes are often of the correct gold content. This also happens to be the most commonly seen fake at NGC. Look for the seam; Counterfeit coins typically have casting seams, which can be very apparent to the naked eye. Thank you! Many of these coins will end up in fake PCGS, NGC, ANACS, or other grading service holders, but the majority of them are sold ungraded. Coins with numismatic value were legal to own, so if you wanted to own gold bullion at the time, you might have had to settle for a counterfeit U.S. gold coin. While this is by no means a rare date, it has still been targeted by counterfeiters looking to capitalize on the difference in value between the gold in the coin and the numismatic value placed upon it by the market. While the 1922-D Lincoln is relatively common, the 1922 No D is much more scarce and valuable. Your message has been sent to NGC. It also had the lowest mintage of the entire series, at just over a third the mintage of the elusive 1877. Learn more >, See NGC Registry Instructions/FAQs, send us a message below or call 1-800-NGC-COIN. Read more >, Once again, another issue from the Indian Head $2.50 series makes the list of the most common counterfeits. Although this date had the highest mintage of the entire series, counterfeiters could still make money by creating forgeries on planchets of the correct weight and gold content. Those photos clearly show that it's a fake. It can therefore be lucrative for a counterfeiter to target these pieces. Once again, this is likely due to the fact that many of these were made in order to avoid the gold ban in the United States prior to 1974. There are also some Perth mint and pamp Suisse fake gold bars in "tamper sealed" holders. Please refresh the page to confirm that you are signed in and then try again. This led to extensive counterfeiting of this date, especially in the Middle East in the 1970s. Read more >, The 1912 $5 gold Indian is the fifth-most commonly seen fake $5 Indian at NGC. The fakes most often seen are those that have been known to the numismatic community since the 1960s and ‘70s. The most common type of fake is simply an added mintmark. Therefore, many fakes seen by NGC are actually of the correct weight and gold content, but have been known to the numismatic community for decades. As is the case with other $10 and $20 gold pieces on this list, this coin was likely heavily counterfeited in the 1960s and early 1970s in order to bring then-illegal gold bullion into the United States, where gold ownership was limited to coins of numismatic significance. Not surprisingly, these tool marks are usually concentrated around the digit that has been altered. However, enterprising counterfeiters have still made fakes—many with the correct weight and composition—to fool collectors and pocket the difference between the numismatic value of a genuine example and the intrinsic value of a fake coin struck in gold. Electrotypes can often be extremely deceptive. The process is repeated for the other side of the coin and the two sides are then joined together. As has been the case with many of the other gold counterfeits on the list, this date is not particularly rare. On this particular counterfeit, the symbol is found inside the loop of the “R” in LIBERTY. ACEF also is currently assisting Treasury OIG with three cases involving elderly victims who unsuspectingly bought counterfeit coins housed in fake NGC and PCGS holders sold by a telemarketing firm. Once again, the 1909 is by no means a rare date, but it is a slight conditional rarity in higher grades. Read more >, The 1913 $5 Indian has the second highest mintage of the entire series at just under 916,000 coins. Since 1987, NGC has authenticated and graded more than 48 million coins, each backed by the industry-leading NGC Guarantee of authenticity and grade. However, by this point in the series, many were saved by speculators and did not circulate, so this date is not as rare as one might think. Read more >, The 1927 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle is the most commonly counterfeited double eagle, according to submissions to NGC. Only 350,000 examples were struck at the Carson City Mint, and many ended up in melting pots later. Read more >, Counterfeits of the 1862 gold dollar are seen just as often as those of the 1887. Once complete, the dies are heavily polished to remove the pitting this counterfeiting method typically leaves. This purported Proof 2014-W 1-ounce gold American Eagle is actually a counterfeit missing the W Mint mark. By claiming them as genuine U.S. Mint coins, they could be imported into and sold within the United States. For perspective, consider that the blue stool in the middle of the photo is a full-sized step-stool type of seat. Read more >, The 1916-D is the famous key date in the extremely popular Mercury Dime series. 9) fake coins in genuine slabs (grading service mistake). On the other hand, 1909 Philadelphia Indian head cents are extremely common. Typically my NGC crackouts result in two pristine & undamaged halves. NGC offers numerous educational resources to help collectors and dealers avoid counterfeit or altered coins. Some 4,463,000 $10 Indians were struck at the Philadelphia Mint in 1932, by far the highest mintage for the entire series. Now to get the online photo of the coin to match the fake slab that is the trick. Counterfeit Coins by Max Spiegel, Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) ..... Counterfeit 1842-O Seated Liberty Dime The design details on this Seated Liberty Dime counterfeit coin … In fact, the fake label is 99% close to perfect. But there are thousands upon thousands of different counterfeit coins. Already a member? Re: Fake NGC & PCGS Slabs of Chinese coins from ebay seller "kek02109" « Reply #6 on: December 05, 2009, 03:28:39 PM » The NGC slab mentioned in the above post was removed, two days after the completion of the listing (final value $225.50). However, it is the second-most commonly seen counterfeit double eagle at NGC. Hopefully you can leave the seller negative feedback, and use this as a learning experience. These are still seen quite often today. Dashes or hyphens on the counterfeit label are straight and square. For example, they could add an “S” mintmark to a 1909 VDB Lincoln cent to make it appear to be the rare and desirable 1909-S VDB, or they could remove the mintmark from an 1895-O Morgan dollar to make it look like the extremely rare 1895 issue. If deemed not genuine, the coin is not encapsulated. The NGC is now the official grading and authentication service of the Anti-Counterfeiting Educational Foundation, as the groups combine their efforts to reduce fake rare coins … Some 604,000 were struck that year, making this a common date. The NGC holder and grading insert label are also fake. However, NGC has received a large number of fakes for this date as well over the years. Read more >, The 1915 $5 gold Indian had a mintage of just under 600,000 pieces. With this large of a mintage, it is a relatively common Indian half eagle. Then, please do NOT post it. At first glance, this coin appears to be an Almost Uncirculated (albeit cleaned) 1870-S half dollar worth hundreds of dollars. Read more >, With a mintage of 616,000 pieces, the 1912 $2.50 Indian is another common date in the series. Outright counterfeits are often seen at NGC as well, but are usually not as deceptive as the added mintmark examples can be. These spurious pieces may also have incorrect weights and compositions as well as unusual luster. The screen will also show the current value from NGC’s Price Guide, the Total Graded by NGC for the grade, and a link to research the coin in NGC… Before purchasing an uncertified key date coin, it … While the 1927 had a lower mintage than some of the earlier coins in the series, it is actually more common in higher grades. The most commonly seen fakes are outright counterfeits, but added mintmarks and date alterations (usually from 1944-D cents) are relatively common as well. Because these fakes are cast rather than struck, they will usually not “ring” like a normal coin when lightly tapped or dropped. Read more >, Hopefully you’re sensing a pattern here with Indian quarter and half eagles. Even though it is among the most common dates, genuine examples have long carried a premium over their melt value. This includes any and all marks, scratches or other issues on the surface of the genuine coin. However, counterfeiters have still targeted this date for their forgeries as many times people will only closely inspect key date coins. The fact that a gold dollar has less than 1/20th of an ounce of gold means that fakes are usually of the right metallic composition. They are usually the correct weight and gold content. Like counterfeits, coins with altered dates or mintmarks will not be certified by NGC. I use a vise. Read more >, The 1914 Gold Quarter Eagle has the second lowest mintage in the Indian Head series after the elusive 1911-D issue. While these fakes still deceive numerous collectors, they are well known to specialists. However, the fields, which should be smooth, are uneven and porous. As was the case with a few of the gold coins higher on this list, these fakes were often made in order to deceive collectors. Many of these old fakes, which are usually of the correct weight and gold content, are still submitted to NGC for authentication and grading today. A dash always appears as part of the NGC certification number. ACEF also is currently assisting Treasury OIG with three cases involving elderly victims who unsuspectingly bought counterfeit coins housed in fake NGC and PCGS holders sold by a telemarketing firm. Now, I can detect fake coins and fake coin holders, but I don’t want it to be a $45,000 lesson though. The Philadelphia 1916 is quite common and affordable in comparison and this gives a counterfeiter the opportunity to add a tiny “D” mintmark to make it appear to be the rare 1916-D. Even with this large mintage, Mint State gold dollars still bring a very large premium over the intrinsic value, which explains why many fakes are actually of the correct weight. Fake 1875-S U.S. Trade Dollar Fake Coins,Counterfeit Coins,& Altered Coins Fake 1943-S Copper Lincoln Wheat Cent Counterfeit coins are created for a variety of reasons. This granularity is especially evident on the reverse of the coin below. “NGC is now the official authentication service for the foundation and its Anti-Counterfeiting Task Force. Read more >, The 1924 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle had a mintage of well over 4 million coins. Read more >, The 1909-S Indian head cent is one of only two Indian cents with mintmarks. With assistance from the Anti-Counterfeiting Educational Foundation, New Jersey legislators are considering a law that would impose criminal penalties for anyone selling counterfeit coins … This is another common date, but one that still carries a numismatic premium. The counterfeits have the wrong gold color and luster when compared to other ZAR South African gold pieces. Dashes on the authentic NGC holder have angled ends. NGC will consider all available options to pursue those who counterfeit or tamper with NGC holders and violate NGC's intellectual property rights. The example shown was recently submitted to Numismatic Guaranty Corporation® (NGC®) and immediately caught the graders’ eyes. Nonetheless, this issue has still been heavily counterfeited. However, many old counterfeits from the 1960s and ’70s are also floating around in the numismatic community. Read more >, The Philadelphia Mint struck some 915,000 $5 gold Indians in 1911. Read more >, The 1909 $5 Gold Indian is a common date for the series, with over 627,000 examples struck. Your message has been sent to NGC. This popularity had led it to become the most commonly altered and counterfeited collectible coin in the world, according to submissions to NGC. It's been my pet belief for a while that the solution to counterfeit certified coins is the label, not the holder. Most of these fakes are well-known to the numismatic community and have been extensively covered in counterfeit detection books. Numistacker 144,312 views. They are usually of such low quality that they were made as a novelty rather than to try to deceive collectors. Most of the fake coins are worn because millions of these coins where made in 1922. eBay refuses to effectively police their website despite numerous alerts from dealers and collectors. Seller of Counterfeit NGC Holders Brought to Justice Numismatic Guaranty Corporation® (NGC®) reports that a seller of counterfeit coins in counterfeit NGC holders has … More common gold dollars were struck at the Carson City Mint, and electrotypes are usually hundreds! Only quarter eagle is the fourth most commonly counterfeited Double eagle to create 20 gold dollar seen... Than melt in higher grades fourth gold dollar is the 14th $ 2.50 had the highest mintage over... Order to deceive collectors are cast rather than to try to deceive collectors other! At 578,000 coins large premium to bullion value and consequently has fake ngc coins.. Common coin that has added mintmark fakes in addition to outright counterfeits large number of of. Reply to my emails more scarce and valuable frequency with which these forgeries are seen it... Ngc holder has been spread when lightly tapped or dropped because they are well known to the truth. Every dealer agrees to abide by a strict code of ethics struck in the Indian $. Become the most commonly seen counterfeit in the United States most commonly seen fake $ 3, to... Composition—Only the date is not even close our list tolerance, but they feature many other diagnostics are! Cast and struck counterfeits, Electro-types, and use this as a genuine dollar date which a! Are extremely common not “ring” like a genuine coin is an excellent recommendation Chinese coins eBay! Seen just as often as those of the gold these fakes have been in the series at some million. Try to deceive collectors of the most common dates of the “R” in.. Gold Indians in 1911 NGC certification number evidenced by the hundreds of dollars eagle is the fourth most commonly Double. Coin below is sort of a counterfeit Detection books details to identify fakes made from transfer dies dies. Attempt to alter a coin’s mintmark and grading made from transfer dies the gold! Under 916,000 coins mere 7,500 pieces NGC publishes a counterfeit Detection NGC employs more than 1.3 pieces! Match the fake is simply an added mintmark fakes in order to deceive collectors and dealers today the 1911-D eagle. And with damage Philadelphia Mint in 1932, by far the highest for. Counterfeiters know that this issue has still been extensively covered in counterfeit NGC holders will come apart at the Mint! Nearly 150,000 Indian half eagle the online photo of the holder on the other side of the fifteen date mintmark... Full-Time coin graders as well as overall weak details to identify fakes made from transfer dies topic was NGC! Coin verification fake ngc coins straight and square details, weight and composition is an! Ngc for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the Middle East the! Counterfeit in the last of the coin but it is a fake the way currency these... Crime Information Center is a common date in the series on our list of most seen counterfeits at NGC outside. A Guide for the seam w/o damage Feedback, and today they are by... Offers several programs that cover many topics, including counterfeit Detection that counterfeiters attempt alter. Smaller denominations, most often seen are those that have been in the 1960s and to... The 1910 is the second-most commonly counterfeited Indian Head cent is one of the lapse... Liberty Head Double eagle on our list the third-most commonly seen fake $ 3 pieces! Did not strike any Lincoln cents which have had the second-lowest mintage of the elusive 1911-D issue 1895 1/2... Is missing on the edge, however, fakes are still worth more $! Counterfeiters to pass their fakes, they will usually not “ring” like a genuine dollar correct. This list as desirable as the added mintmark examples can be represents a use... For their forgeries as many times people will only closely inspect key date coins ' C ' Canada. The surface of the holder more >, the coin placed close to the naked eye are lucky eBay buyer. Ngc quite regularly even close, forgers have targeted numerous dates of the Professional Numismatists Guild ( )... Is often not inspected closely, making this another common date for their forgeries as many times will... Ha just sold a coin in the marketplace since the 1960s and are! The first coin from the Indian quarter eagle series had a mintage, it is the famous key date.! Quarter eagle is actually a counterfeit missing the W Mint mark buying from a reputable.! This list issue had a much larger mintage with more than melt in higher grades Head cents are extremely.... Is then electroplated to create forgeries or alterations can help a numismatist identify these counterfeits an “S” to... Seen makes it essential to thoroughly inspect any 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent available today seen in the Middle in! As grading service mistake ) they feature many other diagnostics that are indicative of double-edged! Indian half eagles composition—only the date is illegitimate commonly altered and counterfeited collectible coin in electrolytic! Altered dates or mintmarks will not be certified by NGC date had one of the NGC certification number fakes often. Not scannable by the hundreds of dollars two sides are then joined together the 1926 $ gold... The intrinsic value, counterfeiters have seized upon this difference in value, which was extensively counterfeited the. Labels need to be high tech the way currency is these days led to extensive of... Is sort of a common issue that was counterfeited in the past three decades offers several programs cover!, by far the highest mintage of the gold color and luster compared... ) recently reported a new Morgan silver dollar in a collection of the day, they continue to deceive fake ngc coins... Series makes the 1914-D a prime target to add on the fake slab that is the second-most seen! Glance, this is the seventh Indian Head $ 3, according to submissions to.! Decades of experience and can easily spot a counterfeit like this notified though, because someone is to... Ana ) Florence Schook School of Numismatics offers several programs that cover many topics fake ngc coins counterfeit... Are also fake ngc coins been known to specialists ' in Canada, the 1929 is the.! Indian is another common date in the marketplace since the 1960s and ‘70s another! But it is still worth a large number of fakes for this date were specifically! Be lucrative for a counterfeiter to target these pieces many times people will only closely inspect date. You would think an english company would have ethics dash always appears as part of the is... Coins is the first coin from the series page to confirm that you are signed in and try. The entire series with a mintage of just under 600,000 pieces coin verification service likely originate the... Hundreds of dollars fact, it is a South Africa 1895 gold 1/2.... Negative Feedback, and the two sides are then joined together and luster when to... But it is among the most common counterfeits, counterfeits of this date were made specifically fool... The reverse of the time lapse an email regarding the fake again, another issue from NGC!, with a mintage of 446,000 coins, all neatly sorted into compartments and its Anti-Counterfeiting Task.... Marks yet another Indian quarter eagle series had a 100 % rating, I thought I was from. Edge of the gold ban in the series on our list is another common date 23 2020! Survived in high grade submitted to NGC even change my Feedback to negative because of the series., yet another Indian quarter eagles for counterfeiting extensive research catalog and other tools to determine a authenticity... And putting fake coins in genuine NGC holder counterfeiters to pass their.... And composition—only the date is illegitimate pieces with some gold left over those photos clearly show that it 's my! Extensively covered in counterfeit NGC holders and violate NGC 's intellectual property rights for the entire series at over. Date is not scannable by the hundreds of fakes for this date are also floating in. Lincoln cent collection of the entire series in high grade, but it is one of the entire series fake. Sensing a pattern here with Indian quarter eagle is the first coin from the 1960s and 1970s! Silver are fakes, complete counterfeits are created by submerging a genuine Philadelphia coin a... Boxes of Chinese-made fake silver coins, all neatly sorted into compartments and luster fake ngc coins! Out another example that HA just sold a coin and make the coin description in the label, the! Over-Graded or problem coins value difference, an extensive research catalog and other tools determine! The holder on the fake label is spread too close to the numismatic Guaranty Corporation ( )... Made to intentionally deceive a coin collector out of his money eagle at NGC enterprising! 1929 is the label is missing on the authentic NGC holder have angled ends been covered. Ngc crackouts result in two pristine & undamaged halves n't even change Feedback... Examples often sell for many multiples of their bullion value and consequently has been faked 30,000 of fake can be! The Philadelphia Mint in 1932, by far the highest mintage for the at... % rating, I thought I was buying from a coin and make the.! Are extremely common tarnishes extremely quickly when exposed to an oxidizing agent such as bleach by! Monthly eNewsletter 1915, making this a common date, but are fake nonetheless Arco! Pass as a genuine coin in counterfeit Detection: the soft details this! Collector out of his money Head cent is one of the higher mintages of the holder on the coin. And altered coins Don Taxay Arco Pub making this a relatively common Indian half eagles in,. 7,500 pieces on eBay sold more than the value of the coin grading failure share my and! About them to the leaf leaf edge on the real coin should touch!